Many thanks for all the replies. I do have all the information of the family following the marriage. Sorry about misreading 35 for 55. Interesting that it was to let in 1862. 55 is still among the missing houses in Spencer Street in the 1861 census. In the 1851 census the house numbers have not been transcribed in FindMyPast, but it can be found by scrolling through the images.
The whole record of the marriage is a bit odd. It states the Charles Brooke's residence was Wimbledon, Surrey, but I can't find any connection there. He was born in Wistaston, Cheshire, and lived for a few years in Liverpool after his marriage, before moving to Nantwich.
I can find no record of the birth of a Lizzie Bayley, but there was an Elizabeth Bailey baptised in 1846 in North Wingfield, Derbyshire, the daughter of James Bailey, a brickmaker. North Wingfield is near to Chesterfield, the place of birth given for Lizzie in the later censuses. The date fits with the age of 17 at the marriage, and it was stated that the father was James. I'm pretty certain that Elizabeth Bailey must have been Lizzie, even though Lizzie's father was described as a builder, and both parents were living at the time of the marriage.
I thought if I could find the occupants of 55 it might provide a clue, but it might not have been of help.