I am researching a branch of the TILLEY family who moved from Northamptonshire to Nottinghamshire in the 1870s and have run into a mass of confusions and seemingly dead ends.
The indexes show that John William TILLEY married Hannah SHOOTER in the Basford District in OND 1878. The 1881 and 1891 censuses show that they lived in Watnall Road, Hucknall and that Hannah's year of birth was about 1853. These censuses also show three children: Mary Ann, Samuel and Louisa. Hannah died in 1891.
First mystery: in 1911 John William (living with daughter Louisa) declared that there had been five children of which two had died. - who were these other two?
Second mystery: Who was Hannah Shooter - and who were her parents?
Between 1880 and 1891, the GRO indexes list four births in Basford with MMN Shooter. This fourth one was Edna born in 1882. Edna never appeared with the family in Hucknall. However there is an Edna Tilley listed in the 1891 census aged 9 born in Hucknall Torkard living in Westbury on Trym Gloucestershire. The head is Henry Sheppard (26 also from Hucknall Torkard) who describes Edna as niece. She is in the same household in 1901. Is this the same Edna? and if so how do Henry Sheppard and Hannah Shooter connect.
There is a tree on Ancestry which does claim this Edna to be John William and Hannah's child. However it also gives Hannah's date of birth as 1870 and her parents as John Shooter and Ann Sheppard (born 1843) - mismatch of dates there.
So, are parish registers available on line which might show who Hannah's father was? I'm leaning towards the idea that she might have been born illegitimate before her Sheppard mother married a Shooter.
Many thanks Alan