Forguette, thanks for your continuing interest.
My direct ancestor 5xgtgdfather James Clark in Mains of Buckie married Elspet Andrew. I have that he was born 1724 Burnside [of Buckie] s/o James Clark b c1690, but it's by no means certain this is my ancestor especially where for years many sources had had him, and still do, as b 1727 s/o John Clark & Margaret Robertson in Woodside of Rannes. There are in fact four or five contemporary James Clarks: in Burnside of Buckie, in Rannes then Woodside, in Arradoul, and in Freuchnie (then/and) in Hilton.
If you want a bevy of James Clarks, here's his baptism: "6-1-1724 : James, Lawll Son to James Clark & Janet Clark in Burnside was baptized witnesses James Clark in Woodside & James Clark in Arradoul." - Rathven OPR. I like to understand the relationship of the witnesses to the parents.
Anyway, that's not the issue. His father was James Clark who married first his cousin Janet Clark then secondly Isobel Geddes: this James Clark was in Burnside of Buckie throughout. That's settled as much as it will ever be.
But my research is earlier up the Janet Clark line as well as earlier up the James Clark line, along both of which is where you hit multiple James Clarks. One such being James Clark in Arradoul (I have deemed him the witness in 1724) who married Isobel Ritchie abt 1706 (she died in Stonyfold); they had a son James Clark in Arradoul and/or Stonyfold and/or the Rodin who had the illeg child James Clark.
The Rathven OPR is easy to search -
http://charlesflett.co.uk/genealogy.htm I have downloaded each transcribed segment and combined them into one searchable file.
I am fortunate in also having a complete set of photos of the actual microfilm so I can verify the transcription. (No, I am not offering lookups - use ScotlandsPeople!)
So I probably have harvested every occurrence of Stonyfold and variations.
Forfarian, thought you might follow that up! Everything does seem to point towards Manse rather than Mains.
To sum up, I'm going to have to accept for the moment that Rodin/Rodden is the prior name that persisted occasionally for what became the Manse of Rathven (plus glebe) and whatever dwellings there were associated with it, and that the couple James Clark (being son of James Clark a heritor in Arradoul and a Kirk Elder & Isobel Ritchie) & Jean Watson were in Arradoul at the time of their illeg child's birth and baptism in 1732. Jean Watson disappears (possibly with the child) and James Clark marries Margaret Green in 1734. Full of holes, but where would we be if we ever completed our research?