I am working with my and 2C Mary Ann AncestryDNA matches. Our great grandfather was Edward R. Hughes b. 7 Mar 1845 Tanywal, Abergele. Our great grandmother was Mary E. Evans b. 1850 Ohio and was illegitimate. Her mother, Ann Evans, was born 01 Nov 1830 Llanfair Caereinion, Montgomeryshire. The three matches I am trying to connect are Mary Ann's matches. In researching these matches I have found some trees that suggest a possible connection to some of my matches. The actual atDNA may come from Evans in Montgomeryshire but we may also share a Denbighshire Hughes ancestor. The 3 matches are gill8399 with the Parry ancestors, SARAHJONES1811 and Gail Jones (probably sisters) with Denbighshire Hughes ancestors .
Edward R. Hughes' father was Robert R. Hughes b. 9 Nov 1818 at Berth, Denbighshire to Hugh Hughes and Mary Hughes from his 1891 obits. I have this in my tree. (Username: Moutrey, Hays Moutrey Davies Hughes tree). But all my cousins have Sarah Williams as Robert's mother. This is because the Jones girls have this in their tree and several of us descendants of Robert R. Hughes have small atDNA matches to descendants of 2 children who have Hugh Hughes and Sarah Williams as their ancestors. Sarah Williams is a very common name in Wales so that the Hugh Hughes b. abt. 1796 Abergele may be the correct Hugh Hughes and my G+ grandfather. Sarah may not be my G+ grandmother.
This is a puzzle I have been working on for more than 10 years and one that I started in my tree years ago when I found an Abergele Methodist birth of a Robert Hughes (twin Elizabeth) born at Berth to Hugh Hughes and Sarah Williams 9 Dec 1821 and baptized 15 Dec. by Rev. Thos. Jones of Moelfre at the dwelling house of Hugh Hughes. My cousins copied this into their trees. I changed his mother to Mary Hughes a few years ago and it was supported by the Robert R. Hughes obits that I found a few months ago. Recently I found a tree with Robert 1821, parents Hugh Hughes and Sarah Williams, who was living in Liverpool by 1851. If that tree is correct Robert 1821 is not my ancestor. I have not found a birth record for Robert Hughes b. 1818 Berth or anywhere else.
Thanks for your interest.
Marian