The medals may not have held such a place in some hearts in the past as they do now. Unless you do know that there was a break in at a specific point in time, I would be tempted to believe they were sold or given away rather than stolen. Lost/mistakenly thrown out is also possible. Value not that great either. Shame isn't it?
Was the Aunt's address used as a point of delivery due to Uncle not having his own home at that point in time. Because the medals were delivered to that address does not mean they stayed there.
Presumably Uncle did not marry and have children as you don't mention this. Are there any other extended family who may know the whereabouts of the medals?
I understand what you say about replica medals - not quite the same thing really ...
After what so many service(wo)men went through I can fully understand why they may not have been wanted. Maybe the reaction after WWI was why WWII medals had to be applied for and weren't inscribed.
There was definitely a break-in. My great uncle was a keen fisherman and all his fishing gear is known to have been taken.
It's possible his aunt nagged him about not having claimed his medals so he's told her to do so, just to stop her nagging
I just don't know
I'd always been told he'd been on a shore base only, never served overseas; so it was a bit of a shock to discover he'd been awarded the Burma Star. That arena wasn't exactly a walk in the park. He was involved with the tank landing craft. Some shore base!
Tis a real shame
I've no idea why the medals were sent to the aunt because my great uncle was living in his late parents home at the time. It's a bit of a puzzle what happened to them. His sister cleared the aunt's place when she died and would have said something if they'd been found there. His nephew cleared his place when he died. There was no sign of them there either.
No, my great uncle didn't marry and didn't have any children either. No one knows what happened to the medals. I know he and my father were close, so maybe he gave the medals to my father and when Dad died his widow tossed them as she did my great uncle's original service record
I think I've done all I can to find the medals and will just have to accept they've gone forever