Kris,
Thanks for the census and info on Mary Jane Phare. According to 1900 Census Ann had 12 children so that leaves 3 unaccounted for.
Ann's birth date from death cert (1914) was November 30, 1823 father was listed as George Hyne but perhaps was mistaken. 1900 Census also lists her birth as November 1823.
Also wondering about William's siblings as I have found a Thomas Phare, and a John Phare in Cleveland at the same time all born England. There is only 1 other Phare (another William) in Ohio in 1870 and not in same county, so it makes me wondering if all related.
1870 Census East Cleveland
Phare, Thomas age 47 Mason, born England
Phare, Mary age 45 born England
Phare, Thomas age 13 born Ohio
Phare, William age 9 born Ohio
1880 Census East Cleveland
Phare, Thomas age 53 Mason, born England
Phare, Mary age 53 born England
Phare, Henry age 23 born Ohio
Phare, W?
age 19 born Ohio
1900 Census East Cleveland
Phare, Henry T. age 43 born May 1857 Ohio, parents born England
Phare, Kate age 47 born November 1852 Ireland, parents born Ireland
Phare, Thomas age 77 widowed, born England November 1822, parents born England immigrated in 1853, naturalized
1860 Census East Cleveland
Phare, John age 36 born England
Phare, Arabella age 39 born England
Phare, John age 10 born England
1870 Census East Cleveland
Phare, John age 46 born England
Phare, Arabell age 50 born England
Phare, John age 19 born England
1880 Census East Cleveland
Phare, John age 56 Carpenter born England
Phare, Arabella age 59 born England
Thanks,
Audie443