Sorry Mary
I didn't look at the date you had submitted as carefully as I should have because I had the marriage between those two at a different date in my records (
and my head) and had assumed it would be the same!
What I had was the IGI records the marriage for Samuel Ferguson and Agnes Boyd in 1863:
Samuel Ferguson Birth: 1838 Of, Holywood, Down,
Agnes Boyd Birth: 1842 Of, Holywood, Down, Ireland
Marriage: About 1863 Of, Holywood, Down, Ireland
Of course, for the above, the source isn't stated and there is the word "about" to consider.
So, yes indeed, if they had married in 1858, that could include James and John. I must admit, having them marry in 1863 would fit tidily with my "second marriage theory"! I'm a little more confused now.
I'm not sure what to think. So many "if"s:That perhaps there the error is in the "family memory" about the "Black" surname and it should in fact be BOYD - that it could be that BLACK was a previous generation?
I'd wonder though why there would be record of their marriage, and birth of two children (Agnes & Ann) but none of James or John? Is it that the Samuel and Agnes Boyd are simply a different family and the names coincidental.
There is also the problem that Agnes' age in the 1881-91 & 1901 Workington censuses are inconsistent (around 1846,1843 & 1840 respectively!) and so I'm not sure of her date of birth - 1846 the latter would only make her 12 in 1858 and at 15, very young to be a mother of James (which is why I thought she might be a step-mother!) Then the potential death record (Free BMD) puts her age 55 in 1902 (ie b 1847ish) - 1840 to 1847 is quite a range. She must have been one of those people who didn't like people to know her age!
I hadn't sent away for the death certificates of the Agnes Ferguson or Samuel Ferguson I found on free BMD because it's a bit expensive when I'm not sure enough that they are the correct people (there were other Fergusons in Workington at the time); And the fact that family stories about burials weren't consistent either makes it even iffyer. Maybe I should reconsider.
HMMM while I'm a little further, I also seem to be back at the beginning!
ard
PS I realize that did in fact have the death certificate of Agnes; I'd forgotten because it didn't have too much revealing info. I have since sent aways for Samuel's and their daughter Annie's. I'm pretty sure now that the Samuel's certificate of death in 1880 is that of my gg grandfather - which at least tells me that he had died in Workington and was also a labourer at the ironworks like his sons