Elizabeth Dobb, which is her baptism? late 1700's

[WideEyedGirl]

Hello all,

I have an Elizabeth Dobb who married a James Fletcher at Sheffield on 30 May 1814.
Elizabeth and James had several children ; Mary Ann, Joseph, Vincent, Catherine, James, Martha and Jane, all born between 1815 and 1829.

I'm trying to find the parents of Elizabeth Dobb. I've found a few possible baptisms;
1) bap 5 Jan 1794 at Rotherham, born 5 Dec 1793, daughter of Thomas and Martha.
2) bap 18 Jan 1789, Rotherham, born 18 Dec 1788, dau of John and Sarah.
3) bap 6 Aug 1786 at Whiston, born 4 Aug 1786, dau of John and Elizabeth.
(all these baptisms can be found in transcript form - no images - on An***try).

The only problem is, I have no idea which could be correct! Help with this would be greatly appreciated as I can't seem to trace any further back.

Many thanks for any help or advice,
Holly

[BumbleB]

I can only find images for the Rotherham baptisms (BTs).  The only additional information for both entries is that the parents are from Rotherham.  Images for Whiston are supposedly available 1600-1855 but there is no entry in 1786 for Elizabeth - in fact no entries in August at all.

[WideEyedGirl]

Ah that's a shame, looks like this is going to be a tricky one!
Thank you anyway BumbleB