RootsChat.Com

Scotland (Counties as in 1851-1901) => Scotland => Fife => Topic started by: Kenneal67 on Thursday 16 April 20 13:00 BST (UK)

Title: Census Dodgers
Post by: Kenneal67 on Thursday 16 April 20 13:00 BST (UK)
Maybe the Fife forum isnt the right place for this but I was wondering if anyone else has a family group that appear to have dodged or not been recorded in any census records?

I have Hugh McKenna probably born in Ireland married Catherine Carlan ( also probably born in Ireland) in Ayr in 1833. I have Hughs death record in Ballingry in 1873 and present was his son in law Michael Reynolds. He was a widower so Catherine died before him.

I cant find Hugh or his family or kids ( Elizabeth 1840 Kilmadock / Doune, Hugh 1843 Stirling and John 1848 Falkirk) in any census records from 1841 to 1871.

Its a bit weird
Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: Liviani on Thursday 16 April 20 13:05 BST (UK)
There are some Fife parish census records that are lost/destroyed, this could explain things?

https://www.nrscotland.gov.uk/research/guides/census-records/1841-census#Missing

EDIT: This would obviously only apply to 1841.

I've checked A*cestry and there seems to be another family with a Hugh and Catherine McKenna living in Govan, Glasgow for a period of time, but the places of birth don't match up.
Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: Crumblie on Thursday 16 April 20 13:23 BST (UK)
Elizabeth married in 1866 in Cowdenbeath and her mother was deceased by then.
Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: MaureeninNY on Thursday 16 April 20 13:29 BST (UK)
Ancestry 1841 census has:
Hugh McCenen  30 Lab. born Perthshire
 Catherine McCenen  22 born Ireland
 Sally McCenen  7
 Elizabeth McCenen  1
 James Adams  20

Doune South Street

Maureen
Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: Kenneal67 on Thursday 16 April 20 13:37 BST (UK)
Ancestry 1841 census has:
Hugh McCenen  30 Lab. born Perthshire
 Catherine McCenen  22 born Ireland
 Sally McCenen  7
 Elizabeth McCenen  1
 James Adams  20

Doune South Street

Maureen


I thought I had covered all alternative spellings , that looks very interesting thank you!!
Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: MaureeninNY on Thursday 16 April 20 13:50 BST (UK)
I guess "Sally" on the 1841 is Sarah:
Sarah Mcanna
Marriage Date:
4 Dec 1853

Marriage Place:
Carnock,Fife,Scotland

Spouse:
 Francis Clark 

Elizabeth seems to be with them in Carnock 1861.
Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: Kenneal67 on Thursday 16 April 20 13:57 BST (UK)
I guess "Sally" on the 1841 is Sarah:
Sarah Mcanna
Marriage Date:
4 Dec 1853

Marriage Place:
Carnock,Fife,Scotland

Spouse:
 Francis Clark 

Elizabeth seems to be with them in Carnock 1861.

That is even more interesting Maureen as Francis Clark was a witness at the wedding of Michael Reynolds ( Hughs son in law and informant at his death) and Elizabeth McKenna
Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: MaureeninNY on Thursday 16 April 20 14:16 BST (UK)
They really are tough to find!

Do you know if the two sons (Hugh and John) survived?

Maureen


Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: Kenneal67 on Thursday 16 April 20 14:39 BST (UK)
Hi Maureen

I am afraid I dont
Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: MaureeninNY on Thursday 16 April 20 15:00 BST (UK)
I think I'm out of ideas! :)

Hopefully someone else will spot something.

Good luck,
Maureen
Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: rosie17 on Thursday 16 April 20 16:24 BST (UK)
Not much help with the census records but this looks a possible death for Hughs wife

1862 Scotlands People Catherine  McKennan age 47 years Kilsyth other name Carlin mothers maiden name Thomson

Rosie
Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: MonicaL on Thursday 16 April 20 20:46 BST (UK)
I guess "Sally" on the 1841 is Sarah:


Sally and Sarah are first name variants, see www.whatsinaname.net/php/search.php?action=search2&search_name=sally

Monica
Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: MonicaL on Thursday 16 April 20 21:51 BST (UK)
Could this be another daughter for Hugh and Catherine in the RC Registers on SP?

MARY ANNE MCKENNA
HUGH MCKENNA/CATHERINE CAROLAN
6/7/1857
2/8/1857
Lennoxtown, St Machan's

Elizabeth's baptism in 1840 also shows mother Catherine as Carolan. You mentioned she was born in Doune/Kilmadock, but her christening shows on 26/4/1840 at Stirling, St Mary's.. There looks to have been an earlier born Elizabeth in 1838:

ELISABETH MCKENNA
HUGH MCKENNA/CATHARINE CAWLAN
17/5/1838
10/6/1838
Lennoxtown, St Machan's

And a further daughter:

CATHERINE MACKINNA
HUGH MACKINNA/CATHERINE CAROLAN
5/9/1845
28/9/1845
Stirling, St Mary's

Also, maybe connected with a different variation on mother's maiden name:

MICHAEL MCKENNA
HUGH MCKENNA/CATHERINE KERNAN
0/0/0
8/7/1854
Dunfermline, St Margaret's

In summary of possible children (some to be confirmed):

Sarah b. 1833-4
Elizabeth b. 1838
Elizabeth b. 1840
Hugh b. 1843
Catherine b. 1845
John b. 1848
Michael b. 1854
Mary Ann b. 1857

So, where are they all?!

Monica

Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: MaureeninNY on Thursday 16 April 20 22:46 BST (UK)
I wonder about this family:
Kilsyth; ED: 4; Page: 9; Line: 3 1861 census (Ancestry)

Address: Brickrow
Hugh Mckinnon  32
 Catherine Mckinnon  46
 John Mckinnon  12
 Michel Mckinnon  7
 Mary Mckinnon  3

So difficult to tell when you can't see the original image.

Maureen

Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: MonicaL on Thursday 16 April 20 22:48 BST (UK)
Children showing fit well with what we have potentially so far. Well done, Maureen. Could well be them.

Monica
Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: Kenneal67 on Friday 17 April 20 07:48 BST (UK)
I guess "Sally" on the 1841 is Sarah:


Sally and Sarah are first name variants, see www.whatsinaname.net/php/search.php?action=search2&search_name=sally

Monica

I bought that death record and it says Catherine wife of Hugh a coalminer father John Carlin mother Sarah Thomson

Thanks Ladies
Title: Re: Census Dodgers
Post by: rosie17 on Friday 17 April 20 10:19 BST (UK)
That's good that was the right death the census Maureen found I would say that's the right family in Kilsyth

Rosie