RootsChat.Com

What about "security" for the first word?

I have a big 20 year old question mark regarding my relationship to a known ancestor. My hunch is he (and his wife) are my 4x gr grandparents, parents of my 3x great, Job, and my recent DNA results on ancestry seem to support this.
However, it appears on paper his son is my 4th, here's why. And please bear with my attempt at being thoroughly clear.
John Baker (1816), eldest son of Samuel, & wife, Sarah, had a son, Job (1835), baptized privately at home in Newfoundland.
A year later, John's parents, Sam and Jane, had a son, "John" (1836), baptized in a church.
I contend that the baby, Job (1835), died soon after the private baptism, and Sam's son, baptized as John (1836) is actually my Job.
My reasoning:
First of all I know it's not absolutely impossible, but why would Sam and Jane name two sons, John? I am sure John (1816) survived, resettled in Notre Dame Bay abt. 1840, and had more children, thus they didn't name the baby, "John" (1836), in his memory. Samuel remained in Carbonear.
Secondly, when my Job married in 1859, his residence is give as Carbonear, indicating he never left with John (1816). Also, Samuel is named as a witness at the marriage.
Thirdly, Samuel and Job were entered as witnesses at the marriage of one of Samuel's daughters. If my Job was John (1816)'s son, he would be the nephew of the bride. That would be odd, especially given the fact that she had many brothers who could have been witnesses.
Fourthly, Baby Job (1835) must have been in a dire situation. Newfoundland in the 1830s in November was a cold rugged place. For a priest or reverend to be called out to a private residence there must have been an immediate need.
Fifthly, My Job named 2 of his children, Samuel and Jane, as well as the same names of Samuel's other children. None were named John or Sarah.
And finally we come to my DNA matches. So as to not have a ridiculously long post I'll try to come up with a concise way to summarize in a new post. This has been one of my brick walls for so long, I would be very grateful for all thoughts and insight.
Stephen

Hello,
I'm looking for any leads on William Lowry (b. 1800) and wife, Jane (Callan), who were located in Drummay, Newton-Cunningham during 1830s-50s. They were Presbyterian.
His parents were Andrew and Margaret Browne.
He had 4 children with Jane:
Susan b. 1830 Married John Craig in Ruskey, 1848.
Margaret (my direct): b. 1832
William: b.1835
James: b. 1837
He remarried in 1838 to Mary Crumlish, of Peter and Polly (Loughrey) and they all immigrated to Massachusetts c. 1851. I'd like to find anything on his parents, as well as anything about Jane Callan. I have the feeling they are connected to a Lowry family in Binion, but I'm not sure.
Thanks very much!

  That's got to be it, Zefiro! Thanks very much to you, Brazilian Bombshell, and Karen for your help.
The child baptized here is whom I believe to be my 3rd great-grandmother.