Thanks for the replies Mo & June
The Sophia Harriett problem looks easily explainable, though why at least 3 should pop up all at once is curious! I am trying to get a lead into Alitha's marriage to Robert Henry DRAKE, but looks as though it might predate civil registration. He was a "mariner" so the marriage could have been anywhere from Lowestoft to Liverpool
BEAN as a middle name I guess is possible, but even the people on the Suffolk FHS list admit the name just does not appear in the area around Lowestoft; and there seems no reason for it. You have hit on the other problem - the occupations do not match. The marriage cert says farmer (or just possibly farrier); Samuel ANDREWS (and most of his sons) were shoemakers, consistently from the parish registers through all the relevant censuses.
There's nobody staying with them in any censuses. Yes the name Alitha (or one of its may variants, usually just Alice in the Liverpool censuses
) is one of the strong pieces of circumstantial evidence that she is the daughter of Samuel ANDREWS and Hannah ALGAR, which would make Alitha ALGAR her aunt. Although the name enjoyed some popularity, it was again uncommon the the Lowestoft area. Alitha's children were called Samuel & Hannah (and she had brother & sister with those names)!! And Hannah Jr gave the name Alethea to both her daughters (how much circumstantial evidence does one need
)
The 1865 death is indeed Alitha. I had not seen the 1877 death, but from the birth of the same name registered in 1875 I suspect that this is the daughter of son Samuel, there is a gap in his offspring - well spotted
Still hoping it's just an error on the certificate
Regards
Brian