Thanks for the amazing work on this, folks!
Shellyesq - I was initially reluctant to believe in this one as the children and the story differ from what I believed to be the case. Once I found the reference to John F and Mary Nevin I googled them and found that there had been a couple of that name living in Manhattan. They had two children - Marjorie in 1917 and Margaret (it is thought) shortly afterwards. The belief was that father John F had died in 1919. Hence this differs from what I was expecting. But, as we know in family history, don't always expected the expected!
"« Reply #2 on: Today at 12:18 »QuoteThe census look like 2 good matches. Age of Mary is off on both - making her birth year 1896 or 1892 which might be a puzzle."
If this is 'my' Mary, could she have consistently lied about her age? If she came to America in, say, 1907, she would already have been 19 - to have married in 1917 would have made her 29 - something which perhaps many men of the time would have considered unfavourably old?
Re: the Geraldine F who dies 1997, if that woman does belong to John and Mary...then it is not 'my' Mary and we are back to square one again! But the finding of Audrey having the same birthday does suggest that this is *this* family - a family of John Fitzgerald and Mary Boyle...rather than John Fitzgerald and Mary Nevin. I think that these census records then have to be discounted.
UNLESS Mary Nevin remarries after John's death - to a Mr. Boyle. Hence when Geraldine provides the data on her parents she names her mother as "Mary Boyle"? Is this feasible?
"This appears to be Mary's passenger list to New York -
https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:JXYX-XM7 Father's name looks like Frank Nevin, Loseria?, Nenagh, Tipperary."
Amazing find. However, I think that the place name is 'Roscrea' - quite some miles away from where the family was living. I don't have evidence for there being a Frank Nevin living around there...but it is a discrepency that would need sorting out. There are two Mary Nevins in the 1901 census around North Tipperary who aren't mine - both are living as servants, and I've not yet ascertained their parentage. Someone with access to Rootsireland might be able to help re: seeing if any other Frank/Mary combos were around at the time...
"« Reply #5 on: Today at 14:20 »QuoteThis WWI draft registration card for a John Fitzgerald born Providence, Rhode Island -
https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:KXYV-Z5Y - gives the same address as the one above in the 1920 census. However, he is listed as married, but it was dated 5 Jun. 1917, which would have been before the Nov. 1917 marriage date."
Confusingly, I've also found a reference to the marriage (on Ancestry) giving the date as May 1917! If that was the case...then this could well be him. But as I said, this appears to be a John F who married a Mary Boyle...thus is not the one referred to in the marriage cert.