24953
« on: Thursday 23 February 06 15:31 GMT (UK) »
Many thanks, Forfarian, for your very helpful reply, and especially for pointing me to FreeCEN - I hadn't realised it was so good on the early Scottish censuses. Thank you also for pointing out my error on the family from the "wrong" Kirkmichael. I see from FreeCEN that there is an intriguing John McGregor, college student, aged 19 in 1851 who is staying in Fyvie, Aberdeenshire with the family of a Donald McGregor b Kirkmichael, Banff. John's own birthplace is given as Cromdale, Inverness-shire, which my map suggests borders on the parish of Kirkmichael, Banff. I'm beginning to wonder if he was orphaned early on and could be the same John who was with the Frasers in 1841.
John was mysteriously inconsistent about his age. Here's what I've got from sources where I definitely know it's the right John (i.e. marriage and later):
Marriage certificate (Dundee, Feb 1869): M.D. aged 32
US 1870 census (Avoca, Nebraska Jul 1870): physician aged 31
US 1880 census (Yankton, Dakota Territory Jun 1880): physician aged 42
US 1900 census (Yankton, South Dakota Jun 1900): physician aged 68 DOB Jun 1831
US 1910 census (Yankton, South Dakota Apr 1910): physician aged 78
A handwritten family tree passed down to me from one of the American descendants has John's birthdate written in as 21 June 1831 (his parents not shown on tree), but the person who drew up the tree died 20 years ago so I don't know where he got that from. I am absolutely certain that the marriage certificate and the censuses all relate to the same person because his in-laws, named on the marriage certificate, emigrated at about the same time and father-in-law Robert Barnes was living with John and Mary in Yankton in 1880. John never moved away from Yankton and died there in 1918.
One thing I have noticed from looking at the censuses again is that in 1910 John lists the mother tongue of himself and his parents as Gaelic. I'm hoping this might help me narrow down the geographical areas of Scotland he might have come from (?)
Thank you again for your help.
Anna