RootsChat.Com

I see that much of the information has been posted on previous threads. A summary of the Qld data
is

Qld BDM Records
Marriage 1928 C103 Henry Victor Weber married Isabella Martha Landells
Death 1954 C1395 Isabel Martha Weber Parents William James Landelle Hertha Netzler
Death 1984 57814 Oscar Landells Parents William Landells Phoebe Agnes Netzler

The funeral notice provides the daughters' married names.
Courier Mail 20 Dec 1954 p 14
Landells, Mr. William James, Glenrosa Road, Red Hill.— Relatives and Friends of Pastor and Mrs. Don Whittaker, Mr. W. Landells, Mr. H. V. Weber, Mr. and Mrs. W. P. Miller are respectfully informed of the death of their beloved Father, Father-in-law, and Grandfather. The Funeral is appointed to leave the Parlour, 400 Wickham Street, To-day (Monday), for Mt. Thompson Crematorium, after Service commencing 11.45 a.m. METROPOLITAN FUNERALS

Oscar certainly seems to be the Mr W Landells from the funeral notice - perhaps he was known as William.

Isabella's death index gives her mother as Hertha Netzler,- which could be a transcription error but closer to Henrietta/Etta than Phoebe Agnes.

My best guess would be Oscar was known as William, child of Phoebe
Isabella daughter of Henrietta/Etta - although her marriage certificate might confirm or not.
Both children must have been quite young when their parents died, so they may be using information supplied by their father or step mother.
Faith daughter of Marguerite.

It is an interesting puzzle but unless the marriage records from Samoa exist and can be found - the parent of Oscar & Isabella could be either of the first 2 wives.

...So, it appears if I were to order from the Vic BDM, I would order the 35459 record. However, Westward's suggestion of ordering a NSW transcript sounds eminently more sensible.

If you have anyway of accessing the library copies of the records, that would be the cheapest option (or accessing the CD mentioned by Cando). I don't know if your state library would do a lookup on the NSW films or the CD for you - could be worth an email.

The advantage of having the records in the Vic BDM  index (over NSW) is you get both parent full names on the index. You are fortunate to have the mother's maiden name as on many church baptism records this is not given. I doubt there will be much extra information on these  records, perhaps the occupation of the father/husband - I can think of little else that is not on the Vic Index.

As church records, there may be little more information than is shown in the index. For the birth record - did the family have more children post Jun 1853? If so that civil certificate would give more value for money.

Also - Victoria did not separate from NSW until 1851. Those early records should be in the NSW bdm records and are available in many NSW libraries at no charge. Also available at most state libraries and probably some online sources (pay sites or perhaps familysearch? - I can't find any at the minute)

This is the marriage from the NSW registry
1663/1842 index/year

V18421663 92  This is the code used to find the record in the marriage register

AHERN TIMOTHY MULCAHY ELLEN  Names

LR   - NSW Church code for Melbourne, St Francis (VIC)

Some information about the records in NSW is given here
https://www.records.nsw.gov.au/archives/collections-and-research/guides-and-indexes/births-deaths-and-marriages-registers-1787-1856

Thank you for the replies. I'm still slightly mystified as to why they died on the same day (well, were buried on the same day).

Where did you find the information about the pew in St Aubyn's DOB7?

James' father Alexander started the Linen Drapers & James carried on the business.