Hello again sinned,
Sorry about the guess at 'dennis' - but 'sinned' seemed such an unusual posting name until I relaized that it spelled 'dennis' backwards
Is there any possibility that David married Janet, she passed away, and then he married Margaret?
It might help us to help you if you provide some more details?
Sometimes having all the information just triggers something useful in someone's mind.
For instance, where did David die and are David's occupation, the name(s) of his wife(or wives)/widow, and his father's occupation shown on his 1887 death certificate - and who was the informant? Do you have David in the 1861, 1871 and 1881 Scotland censuses? What is his age, occupation and birthplace in each and who is with him?Incidentally, you say that a 'check with Dumfries' (what was that?) turned up no record of a marriage of a David RICHARDSON to a Margaret GRAHAM.
But there definitely are
extracted records of such a marriage in the online IGI so these must appear in the parish register (though, of course, this marriage may well have nothing to do with your David).
*David RICHARDSON and Margaret Wilson GRAHAM, 8 Oct 1854, Lochmaben Dumfries Scotland; M118404 FHL Film #1067968
*David RICHARDSON and Margaret Wilson GRAHAM, 8 Oct 1854, Dryfesdale Dumfries Scotland; M118204 FHL Film #1067958
And there are
extracted entries of children to a David RICHARDSON and a Margaret GRAHAM in Lochmaben, all C118401 and taken from the Statutory Register:
*Margaret Mitchell RICHARDSON, b 11 Feb 1855
*Thomas RICHARDSON, b 10 Jun 1856
*John James RICHARDSON, b 18 Nov 1858
*Samuel RICHARDSON, b 20 Feb 1865.
Finding this family in (say) 1861 on SP could help rule them out if that David is too young and/or has the wrong occupation and/or has the wrong birthplace.
The only
extracted records in the online IGI for children of a David RICHARDSON and a Janet GRAHAM in Dumfries are:
*Jane Graham Grieve RICHARDSON, bap 12 May 1844, Lochmaben
*Isabella RICHARDSON, bap 26 Dec 1845, Torthorwald
I guess you could order in, to your nearest LDS FHC, the parish films for Tinwald and Lochmaben and trawl through them to see whether you can find David's birth/baptism. Or perhaps wait until more of the Dumfries 1841 comes online at FreeCEN (it seems to be progressing well).
Good luck,
JAP