Fanny TINDALL / FARMERY ??

[hcoldron]

Fanny (Fanney, Frances) married Joseph BOOTH B. 1847

I'm trying to figure out whether it was Fanny FARMERY or Fanny TINDALL.
Both were born in Caistor in about 1849. These are the only ones about the right age I can find on FreeBMD.

The Fanny I'm looking for has her birthplace as Rothwell on the census in 1891, but as Rothwell is just down the road from Caistor this makes sense.

Any ideas what my best course of action is?

[Geoff E]

1851 census has

Fanny TINDALL 1850
Fanny RADLEY 1847
Fanny RINGER 1848
Frances HAMMOND 1851
Frances WOLF 1849

all born Caistor

Fanny FARMERY 1850 Rothwell
Fanny FARMERY 1847 Panton

[hcoldron]

1851 census has
{...}
Fanny FARMERY 1850 Rothwell

I think it's the Fanny FARMERY 1850 Rothwell, as I have her born in Rothwell on a later census:
Booth, Fanny - Barlings Lincoln - Wife - M - b Rothwell Lincs - age 41

[Geoff E]

Perhaps you are looking for this then

Marriages Dec 1876
BAXTER    John        Caistor    7a   1435   
Booth    Joseph         Caistor    7a   1435   
FARMERY    Fanney         Caistor    7a   1435   
TINDALL    Fanny Frances         Caistor    7a   1435

[hcoldron]

Perhaps you are looking for this then

Marriages Dec 1876
BAXTER    John        Caistor    7a   1435   
Booth    Joseph        Caistor    7a   1435   
FARMERY    Fanney        Caistor    7a   1435   
TINDALL    Fanny Frances        Caistor    7a   1435

Yeah, I found that on BMD too, but how do I know which Fanny/Fanney he married!
Based the birth place of Fanny FARMERY that you mentioned, I'm going with that one - until I get the actual certificate!

[Geoff E]

There's a Fanny BAXTER (wife of John) in 1881, born 1859 Lissington living in West Rasen.  Eldest child is age 3.

1871 has Fanny TINDALL age 10 living in Lissington.

This would suggest the FARMERY girl married Joseph BOOTH.