I have put out a few feelers in other directions so awaiting a reply from them. Can't explain in public.
Jane
Very mysterious Jane ...message me, I'm intrigued!
Thanks for the compliment but I'm as flummoxed by this as anyone. Must admit, my first thought when seeing someone using two surnames is, "illegitimate". But I'm sure you've been down that route too and nothing obvious springs out of the available indexes.
I was never convinced by Greasley because, if I remember correctly, our George/William describes his birthplace twice as Nottingham, Notts. A Notts person would know them as very separate places ...unless of course he didn't live there very long. Which brings me to the other possibility, that they weren't a Notts family at all, and he was born there while they were passing through for whatever reason. Winterbottom and it's variants is a very "northern" name.
Neither thought of course, helps much
I hope something comes out of your enquiries Jane. Meanwhile Claire, I'd keep plugging away and collecting all the info you can in the hope it throws up a clue. Do you know what happened to Isabella for example? I was wondering if she also married....I'm also curious about the Phoebe Severs living with Martha and William in 1841 but that's a whole other question, I know!
Heather