Hi, Aggie,
I can help you out some. This is the information I have on your Robert Hoggan, married to Elizabeth McNeil.
1856 Births in the Parish of Slamanan in the County of Stirling
ROBERT HUGGINS
1856, January 13th 7 h. 30 m AM
Newfieldyke
Father: MATTHEW HUGGINS, coal miner
Mother: ELIZABETH HOGGAN, MS PATON
Informant: Matthew Huggins his x mark, father, not present
Robert Main, registrar, witness
1856 January 15th at Slamanan, Robert Main, registrar
**********
1877 in the Burgh of Airdrie in the County of Lanarkon the ninth day of May, at Flowerhill Parish Manse of Airdrie
After Banns according to the Forms of the Established Church of Scotland
Signed: Robert Hoggans, coal miner, bachelor, age 20
Roughrigg, New Monkland
Father: MATTHEW HOGGANS, coal miner
Mother: MARION HOGGANS MS PATON, deceased
Signed: Elizabeth McNEIL, outdoor worker, spinster, age 20
Father: JOHN McNEIL, coal miner
Mother: ELIZABETH McNEIL MS BLACK
Signed: James Paton, minister
Witnesses: John Fleming , his x mark, Marion Hoggan her x mark
1877, May 10, at Airdrie, M. Whyte, registrar
***************
I haven't been able to find Maggie/Margaret's birth, but did find her marriage:
1904, Marriages in the District of Haggs in the County of Stirling
1904, on the 24th day of June at Russell Memorial Hall, District of Haggs
After Banns according to the Forms of the Church of Scotland
Signed: David Anthony, saw miller, bachelor, 24, Wester Seamores,Haggs
Father: William Anythony, general labourer
Mother: Jane Anthony MS MacKenzie
Signed: Maggie Hoggan saleswoman in ? shop, spinster, 24, Banknock,Kilsyth
Father: Robert Hoggan, coal miner, deceased
Mother: Elizabeth McNeil, deceased
Signed: Alexander Robertson, minister of Haggs
Witnesses: George Anthony, Agnes Marshall
1904, June 24th at Haggs, James Robertson, reg.
Matthew Hoggan b. 1878 in Slamannan:
1878 Births in the Parish of Slamanan in the County of Stirling
Matthew Hoggans
1878, January 28th 8 h. AM, Toddsbright, Parish of Slamanan
Father: Robert Hoggans, coal miner
Mother: Elizabeth Hoggans, MS McNeil
1877 May 10, Airdrie
Robert Hoggans, father
1878, Feb. 15th at Slamanan, John Horne, Assist. reg.
1899, Marriages in the District of Haggs in the County of Stirling
1899, on the 29th day of September at Haggs, District of Haggs
After Publication according to the Forms of the Church of Scotland
Signed: Matthew Hoggan, coal miner, age 21 of Distillery Row,Haggs
Father: Robert Hoggan, coal miner, deceased
Mother: Elizabeth Hoggan, MS MacNeil, deceased
and
Christina Donaldson, domestic servant, spinster, 18, of Distillery Row, Haggs
Father: William Donaldson, coal miner
Mother: Agnes Donaldson, MS Miller
Signed: Alexander Robertson, Minister of Haggs
Witnesses: John Ovens, Mary Donaldson
1899 on Sept. 30th at Haggs, James Robertson, reg.
I have the children of Matthew and Christina Donaldson as
Elizabeth McNeil Hoggan b. 1905 (m. William George Williamson)
Matthew
Robert
Is that correct?
Alas, my Robert Sneddon Hoggan doesn't fit into yours except perhaps the fact that Robert (married to McNeil) was a child of Matthew Hay Hoggan and Elizabeth Paton. Matthew Hay Hoggan's parents were Robert Hoggan and Jean Horn, and my great great grandfather may also have been a child of that marriage, which DOES make us related. Have to prove that one, and probably never will.
Rosemary