Hi again all!
I had a very interesting chat with cousin Maria last night and now perhaps have some further avenues to investigate.....
Before I go on, to avoid any confusion, I will refer to David who married Margaret Jaffrey as David snr and to his son (we presume) as David jnr and to his son as Jose David. I don't know about anyone else, but my brain couldn't cope!!
Maria had previously told me that they understood that David jnr had 'gone' to Chile to work on building the railway. He is also understood to have died in an accident at sea, perhaps as a naval employee.
In our chat last night however, another interesting snippet of information came out - apparently Jose David was expelled from the Chilean army for being a Mormon.
Now, Maria vehemently denies that he was Mormon and insists, as does her grandfather, that Jose David was indeed Catholic, even having attended a Catholic school. However, aware as I am of the stigma of the past of being a non-Catholic Chilean, I have to assume there is an element of bias in Maria's assertion. To quote Maria, "years ago... not been catolic... was an insult...".
To be fair though, her grandfather did say that if you were a foreigner back then, you were automatically presumed to be Mormon, whether it was true or not, and I can see that being the case.
However, this had started me wondering whether Jose David was in fact Mormon, courtesy of his father, and his father before him. It could be that David jnr was Mormon and either converted to Catholicism on his marriage to Benigna, or married in the Catholic church to keep his lovely lady and family happy!
If that was the case, it would seem likely, to my inexperienced eye, that David snr had converted to Church of LDS and that this was the reason for his and Margaret's emigration.
I was also thinking, if Jose David joined the Chilean army, they were either not aware of his foreign roots, or that he was Mormon. If the Mormon label was applied to him it would, it appears, be for one of those reasons or the other. He may indeed have been Catholic and it was actually the discovery of his ancestral origins that turned the tide against him.....
Too many questions, I don't really know where to go from here! Any thoughts? I've been accessing LDS for the IGI records since it was pointed out to me as a great source, but I haven't looked at it from the point of view of actual Church of LDS records - does anyone have any suggestions about the best way to go about exploring this now?
Lass x