I am having difficulty with this family as I have proven certificates for Matthew Duncan marrying Helen McAlpine in 1904 (Matthew's parents being John Duncan and Anne Anderson). Matthew was born in 1877 and there was a long list of children on the census returns listed below. On the parents marriage certificate, Anne Anderson's parents are listed as William Anderson and Elisabeth Gray. I have tracked the family through various census returns, checking and cross referencing dates, but on downloading the death certificate for Anne Anderson, her parents are listed as Robert Anderson and Jane Howieson!! Everything else on the certificate checks out (such as the death being reported by her son, Alexander Duncan). I know there were lots of Duncans in the Haggs area, some at Braeface and some at Thomaston (were these farms??) Is it possible there were two John Duncans married to two Anne Anderson?? James died in 1882 and his parents were confirmed on the death certificate as James Duncan and Janet Paterson (which is the same as his marriage certificate); as was the address of Braeface, Haggs.
Census Returns
1891 Matthew was aged 13 living at Braeface, Haggs with Ann Duncan (his mother - a widow) aged 53; Agnes aged 10 and Annie aged 2(illegitimate daughter of Jessie);
1881 - Matthew was 3 living at Thomaston Haggs, with James (father) aged 58, Ann (mother aged 45), Robert 22, David 20, Alexander 17, Jessie 11, Ann 6 and Agnes 1
1871 - the family were at North Thomaston - James and Ann (ages are wrong on ancestry) Thomas 20, John 15, Robert 12, Alexander 7, David 10, ELizabeth 4, Janet (jessie) 2.
1861 - James 38, Ann 27, James 15 and William 14 (from James' first marriage); Thomas 9, John 4 and Robert 1 - living at Upper Thomaston.
Any help regarding the mystery of Anne Anderson's parents, greatly appreciated as my certificates don't confirm what was expected. PM me if you want more info or snippet extracts from certificates.