I am coming to the conclusion that this is the same person. Surely another set of parents wouldn't give their child the same forenames?
Have checked my War Census CD and he is listed as being in Coromandel. I am sure I have seen another marriage for him, it might have been on the NZSG Version 4 CD, but as I have upgraded I can't check.
Looks like I might have to send off for the death certificate.
KHP