Gilby, this is a post I made long ago on genforum concerning this family. My guess is that it would be the second William Walsh McNeill born c. 1835, who married Martha Neill. See below:
1. John McNeill, solicitor, married Catherine Walsh.
2. William Walsh McNeill, d. 1845; m. 1822 Ann Hill, dau of George and Mary Hill of Larne.
3. George Hill McNeill, solicitor; m. 1855 Mary Hudson McNeill, dau of John McNeill, solicitor, of Glenone, Londonderry.
3. Catherine McNeill, b. 1827 m. 1 1852 to J. McNeill, solicitor; m. next to the Rev. John Moore
3. Mary McNeill, b. 1829.
3. John McNeill, b. 1830; m. Mary Jane Hodges
4. George Hill McNeill, b. 1868
4. Elliott McNeill,b. Jan. 25, 1870, d. 1922; m. 1897 Maud Louisa Fry, dau of William Storrs Fry and Anne Jane Lepper
5. Douglas Sidney Elliott McNeill, b.abt. 1898
5. Sybil Ethel McNeill, b. abt. 1901
5. John Macauley McNeill, b. abt. 1903; m. 1929 Thirza Norine Crowe, dau of Dr. George E. Crowe of Didsbury, Manchester(present at their wedding were Sybil McNeill, Helen McNeill, Frank Crowe, and ? Crowe, sister).
4. John Hill Trevor McNeill,barrister, m. Esther Frances Duffey, dau of Dr. Sir George Duffey(she m. 2 John Haltoran Bennett of Ballincurra, Co. Cork).
5. Dorothy Trevor McNeill, b. abt. 1904; 1937 engaged to Timothy Roberts West, M.A., Headmaster of Midleton College, Co. Cork.
6. Dr. Timothy Trevor West, Irish Senator
6. John West
6. Alexander West
3. Ann McNeill, b. abt. 1833
3. William Walsh McNeill, b. 1835; m. Martha Neill
4. Jane McNeill, b. 1871
4. George Hill McNeill, b. 1873
4. Mary Georgina McNeill
3. Eliza Emerson McNeill, b. 1837
3. Jane Hill McNeill, b. 1838
3. Harriet Macaulay McNeill, b. 1844.
Elliott McNeill died? buried? 19 March 1922 aat Dean's Grange Cemetery. Present at funeral were the following:
John M. McNeill
Mrs Anderson, sister
Lewis A. Fry, Ray Fry, Leslie Williamson and Aubrey Marriott, his brothers-in-law
Mrs Manders and Mrs R. Fry, sisters-in-law
Miss K. Manders, niece
-----------------------------------------------------------
1. John Hill Trevor McNeill m. Esther Duffey
2. Dorothy Trevor McNeill m. 1937 Timothy Roberts West, Headmaster of Midleton College, Co. Cork
3. Dr. Timothy Trevor West, Irish Senator
3. John West
3. Alexander West
----------------------------------------------------------