Hi Gadget,
That last post of mine was just aimed at providing a bit more of the (alleged) background to these people and showing what sources for firm "names and dates" are -- so far -- available. As you saw, sadly not many. And that, of course, is the problem.
Don't worry, I had no thought of getting us tied up in the Anglo-Norman stuff! My focus is strictly as set out in my first two posts, i.e. can anyone with Chirk expertise point me at evidence that could remove my growing scepticism about the supposed ownership of Peny Clawdd by a line of Hugheses in the 18th c. and early 19th c. Of course, it is always tough to prove a negative, so the challenge was and is to uncover positive facts about the farm's owner-occupiers during those years. So far, I have found that far from easy -- especially as my local knowledge of Chirk is pretty feeble, at least when compared with yours.
I have now tried the Notitiae; but as you probably thought too, there is nothing very conclusive there -- the only Hughes or Wynne candidates in Pen y Clawdd township being the William Pugh and wife with a 12 year old child, a household that one cannot dismiss, though it does look on the small side. A pity that the clergyman at Chirk did not bother to name householders' wives, in contrast with some of his more industrious colleagues elsewhere.
Thanks for checking the PRs. The absence of any Hugheses who look connected to Pen y Clawdd just sows further doubts about the claims being made; yet without more hard facts I remain reluctant to conclude that John Hughes or his immediate family indulged in wholesale fabrication. A real puzzle. (BTW, the mention of the Pen y Clawdd at Llanasa in the Wikipedia article has not to my knowledge been made elsewhere, and it disagrees with John Hughes's own assertions . . . more fog.)
Although by no means unheard of, it is also relatively rare for a large farmhouse (rather than say an ag labs' cottage or a smallholding) to disappear without any apparent record of exactly when or why. Probably the land had been absorbed into another farm -- as happens pretty frequently -- and then the buildings failed to let or sell and became seriously dilapidated. But it would be good to know more. Perhaps there is still some local "folk memory" about it.
Much appreciate the trouble you have been taking with this.
Rol