Hi Libby, nice to talk to you again
and thanks for the pointers. Very helpful, love the photo site!
Think this is what we have so far:
early 1853, William Brownridge at Scott St, Woodhouse and Ann Atkinson at Nether Green, Woodhouse
1851, best fit for Ann is the servant at 27 Springfield Place, Woodhouse, on both age and location. Next best for location, the one on Myrtle St, although the age is a bit out.
1841, best fit for Ann WAS the one on Grove St, until we realised that John the Tailor was probably too young to be her father.
Then the one on Myrtle St with father or grandfather John. I think I agree with Libby, he is a dresser not a draper - but then if Ann was born out of wedlock, she might have invented the datails on her marriage cert anyway!
Other 1841 sightings of Ann without a father called John include one on Woodhouse Lane with siblings (?) Sarah, Charles and David; then another on Benns Lane (I think) next to Woodhouse Lane, with sibling Thomas and possible grandfather (age 65) Henry.
There are 19 Ann Atkinsons born to father John on IGI Yorkshire. Best fit looks like the one christened at Armley on 18 Jan 1829, parents John and Mary. Would be great if he was a tailor!
I might send for the birth cert/certs of Ann and William's oldest children to see what addresses they have - expensive option, but I'm not sure what else there is to go on..
Barbara