1871 RG10 5012 37 67 in Cory Street Ryhope
William's birth place is Hollingswood Lancs. Age 31 so born c 1840
This confirms everything back to 1871 but now gets us back to more uncertain times. Do you have the marriage certificate for William and Rachel? Sorry, you may have said on another thread but I can't find it. Is that where you got his father as John? Who were the witnesses?
You say that in 1841 William is with his mother Hannah nee Tweddle in 1841 yet the marriage for John at Gretna was to a Hannah Johnston so this does not make sense to me. Is this a typing error?
Regards
Andrea