My scatter gun approach may have paid off. I have been contacted by a Genes re-united member Karen who thinks we may possibly be related.
She has a George Kelman in her family tree who was born on the 1st June, 1885 at
Edinkille, Morayshire, one of 11 children born to James Kelman (1850-1938) who was born at Rhynie, Aberdeen and died at Dyke, Morayshire. His wife was Jessie
Kynoch (1845-1905) born at Dyke and died at Conicavel, Morayshire. They were married in June 1873 at St. Andrews, Elgin.
Now Karen has a great deal of information on all but one of the 11 children which is George who has fallen off her radar screen. Is he the one who gradually moved
South to Liverpool and did James come to live with him after his wife Jessie died in 1905 and then sometime later move back to Scotland?
I have to try and fill in the missing pieces between George's birth in 1885 and his next appearance as husband of Elsie Allen in 1909 and father of my late father-in-law, Thomas George Kelman, born in 1910.
We know that James (1850) was a Joiner by trade (normally associated with an apprenticeship in carpentry, but he might have just joined pipes, vehicles, etc. and thought the description of Joiner suited him better - I'm grasping at straws!)
Likewise George was a sugar refiners assistant but by the time his son Thomas got married in 1937, his occupation of the marriage certificate was listed as a "Carter"!
Fact (I hope so) or fantasy (more likely alas), so the search goes on
Bill