This continues to be quite intriguing. I have more information I'd like to share with you.
James Main, b. abt 1745, m. Mary Mitchell, abt 1766, Slamannan.
James was farming at Balmitchell and died at Heights in 1858; the inventory of his estate was signed by John Main, farmer, Millflats. James owed money to John as well as to William Main, farmer, Balmitchell; they were his sons.
A. Were Mary Mitchell’s parents James Mitchell/Jannet Main, m. 1738, Slamannan?
James Main/ Mary Mitchell; 4 children
1. John, b.1765, to Agnes Russal, while James was working at Burnhead
2. James, b.1768, m. Mary Walker
3. Janet, b. 1772
4. Janet, b. 1776, m. Robert Aitken
B. You mention that John’s paternal grandmother was Catherine Russell. Could you outline that connection for me. In researching Agnes, I found Agnes, b. 1745, Falkirk to James Russell/ Agnes Allan, and an Agnes who married John Tennant in 1769 in Slamannan. Could this be the same one?
C. Were James Main & Robert Main brothers??
I’ve looked at Robert Main/Margaret Gilmour, m. 1737, Barony; 8 children:
1. Peter, b. 1738
2. John, b. 1740; ?m. Agness Ramsay
3. Christine, b. 1742; ?m. James Jackson
4. James, b. 1745 ; ?m. Mary Mitchell
5. Margaret b. 1750; ?m. James Rankine
6. Elizabeth, b. 1753; ?m. Alexander Stewart
7. Robert, b. 1755; ?m. Janet Russell (or Janet Crawford)
8. Alexander, b. 1759; ?m. Agnes Gray
Robert Main/ Janet Russell, m. 1792; 4 children:
1. William, b. 1793, Shieldhill; ?m. Janet Gentles
2. Janet, b. 1796, Airdrie; ?m. Matthew Thomson or James Patterson
3. Mary, b. 1798
4. Marrion, b. 1802; ?m. William Aitkin
John Main/ Isobel Young, m. 1799, Slamannan; 7 children
1. James, b. 1802; m. Matilda Thomson
2. Mary. b. 1804
3. Elizabeth, b. 1807
4. David, b. 1812; m. Margaret Oswald
5. John, b. 1813; m. Helen Mitchell
6. Alexander, b. 1814
7. Alexander, b. 1816
John’s will, 1846, states that he was farming at Easter Glen; he apparently died in 1840. His son David was farming with him at the time. There is a precognition in 1844 against another son, John (my ancestor) for the crime of ‘forgery & uttering’. He forged his brother David’s signature on several promissory notes and in one case, he forged his uncle, James Main’s signature. He ended up in prison for two years.
James Main/ Mary Walker, m. 1793; 10 children:
1. James, b. 1794; m. Janet Fleming
2. William, b. 1806; m. Janet Taylor
3. David, b. 1799
4. Elizabeth, b. 1801
5. Thomas, b. 1803
6. Robert, b. 1808
7. Hanery, b. 1811; m. Elizabeth Kay
8. Mary, b. 1811; m. William Orr
9. John, b. 1797; m. Agnes Walker
10. Janet, b. 1815; m. Henry Taylor
D. The other puzzle I have is that a Thomas Main, b. abt 1773 has been documented in IGI as being a child of James/ Mary Mitchell. He married Janet Forsyth. I don’t think this is correct.