Hello again, ringsfan,
Thank you for your reply, judging by which, your Bayntuns appear far removed from the Wiltshire branches. As I mentioned, their origins stem from Falstone and Bromham, Wiltshire. In fact, I recently paid a visit to the Bayntun Chapel in the Bromham village church - fascinating.
There are memorials to John Bayntun Starky, died 30th September 1878, age 58. Also, Frances Anne, wife of John Bayntun Starky, died 29th March 1921, age 86. Which shows the name Starky to be a link with your branch. The William Bayntun who appears in two of my ancester's wills is still being illusive, perhaps he too is illegitimate. A possible lead is the William Bayntun, born 6th April 1629, Burbage, Wiltshire and his wife Elizabeth Somerset born Abt 1644, Wonston, Hampshire.
Could you please tell me what you know of your Pye connection: christian name, where living, when died, relatives, anything that might give me a clue? Also, I'd be grateful for whatever you're prepared to tell me about your Bayntun connections.
Best wishes
John.