William Dinsdale born 1755

[Tybalt]

I am becoming TERRIBLY confused with two William Dinsdale in my family tree.
The first is William, born 1875, son of Francis S Dinsdale (1845-1895) and Mary Kearton (1852-1904)
The other is William Dinsdale 1873, son of John Dinsdale 1840-1902)and Mary Parkin (1836-1899)
as both these Williams were born in Newbiggin, I am not sure which one married Grace Dinsdale 1873, who is the daughter of Thomas Dinsdale (1840-1917) and Dorothy Percival (1845-1889), I have their children. OR....is she the daughter of Stephen Dinsdale 1844. And Elizabeth Webster(1848-1887). Both these Graces were born in Thoralby around 1873.
All these families are in my tree...
If both Williams married both Graces, which one had the children Elizabeth, 1900, john 1901, Francis,1903 and Robert, 1904.
I am aware this is a very confusing puzzle, but would be very grateful if you could shed any light on this at all, I seem to be going around in circles.
Many Thanks in Anticipation

[daniel1111]

William Dinsdale bap Sept 28th 1873 at Aysgarth was the son of John Dinsdale and Mary (Parkin)
William Dinsdale married Grace Dinsdale Dec 24th 1898 at Aysgarth.
Grace Dinsdale was the dau of Stephen Dinsdale and Elizabeth (Webster) and was bap March 8th 1874 at Aysgarth and was buried April 9th 1904.
They had children:
Elizabeth bap Nov 8th 1899 at Walden
Grace bap Jan 12th 1901 at Walden
Francis bap April 10th 1902 at Walden
Robert born c 1904 He married Rose Annas Atkinson at Askrigg Nov 23rd 1934.

Grace Dinsdale and William Dinsdale were second cousins.

William Dinsdale bap June 14th 1874 at Aysgarth was the son of Francis Spence Dinsdale and Mary Kearton.He died July 6th 1952 at West Burton
This William Dinsdale married Dorothy Harker March 12th 1903 at Aysgarth
Dorothy Harker was the dau of Christopher Harker and Martha (Mudd)
She was born c 1880 and died Jan 7th 1957 at West Burton

Dorothy Dinsdale bap Jan 28th 1880 was the dau of Stephen Dinsdale and Elizabeth (Webster)
She married Christopher Taylor Dinsdale Dec 1918 at Aysgarth.

Grace Dinsdale bap May 25th 1873 was the dau of Thomas Dinsdale and Dorothy (Percival)
She did not marry.

[Tybalt]

Again, so amazed to have sorted this out, everything has now just fallen into place, Thank You SO much, this was such a tangled web and it is now clear,
I can't believe how quickly you replied,
Thanks again