Hi again
I’m sorry you have not been able to make any further progress on this query. Further to what we looked at the other day I have given it a little further thought and come up with a scenario, possibly unwelcome, but a distinct possibility. I think I’m correct in saying that the only evidence of Joseph’s origins come from his marriage certificate, a document that originated in Australia and entirely dependent on a statement by Joseph himself? His death certificate cannot be taken as of any great significanace as it’s probably safe to say that it was based on what was said at the time of his marriage.
Turning to the Joseph that Monica found, I did a little more digging subsequently and was unable to find any UK wide census record of a Joseph recorded as born at Inverness, Dores or similar after 1881. The Joseph who was at Humberston Farm, Dingwall in 1881 (coincidently I was at Humberston Farm last Friday!) was no longer to be found. I looked more closely at the 1871 census record. Although there were 15 persons listed I found that Joseph was clearly attached to the Robertson family. Digging around elsewhere in this part of Scotland I came across other young “boarders”, one of them born in “England”. I then came across this:
http://www.blackshouse.demon.co.uk/Forgotten%20Scots.htmI am doing no more than suggesting one possible explanation in which Joseph is boarded with a family when even younger than nine. When the 1871 census was taken a birthplace was given by someone other than him. He is listed as a scholar so went to school in Dores (possibly Aldourie Primary School) but bear in mind that his home was as close to Inverness as it was to Dores. Ten years later he was working just outside Dingwall. His only memory of his origins would be of Dores so that’s what he gave in the census. About that time there was a demand from New Zealand for Scottish farm workers and he took the opportunity. Arriving in a new country it would be entirely reasoanble for him to build up some sort of identity rather than explain what actually happened. Perhaps the only real fact he could offer was “Inverness”, a major town and more readily understood than a hamlet such as Dores.
As I said, perhaps not a welcome answer but at least a possible one?
Imber