I started to read Shania D'Cruze's
A Pleasing Prospect and in it she mentions the John Bensusan Butt archive, which is a collection of research on about 1,000 people who lived in Colchester in the 1700s. D'Cruze has, since writing the book, put together the research as
downloadable Lulu pdf books called
Colchester People, in three volumes. You won't be surprised to find out that the Mansfield, Marsdens and Waynmans appear in it.
There are 5 entries for James Mansfield (includes summaries of people mentioned in wills, some apprenticeship info, bankruptcy, bits from local papers, who they voted for and when - LOADS of very interesting stuff). Some of it is a little muddled - the Mansfield/Farran marriage is attributed to the wrong James (hey, I'm not surprised, it's confused me too!), but this is what I can work out from the Bensusan Butt archive and what we've found out already....
Our James Mansfield, b abt 1766, who married Mary Tiffin, was the 3rd James Mansfield.
James Mansfield 1st is the man who wrote the 1789 will, which is the date it was written - it doesn't seem to have been proved. In this will he leaves most of his property to his son James 2nd (I had assumed that the son in the 1789 will was James Mansfield 3rd - I was wrong).
In this will, James 2nd has two sons mentioned: Samuel and James. I believe James 2nd's son James is James 3rd (husband of Mary Tiffin).
The 1789 will mentions other grandchildren: Mary, wife of Samuel Wright and Sarah, wife of Charles Heath. This ties in with the 1821 PCC will of James Mansfield, where we have Mary Wright and his grandchildren who are the children of Charles Heath. So therefore, the 1821 will is that of James 2nd, father of James 3rd (it also means we can identify the father of the Mary and Sarah in James 1st's will - it means that James 2nd had at least four children - Mary, Sarah, Samuel and James 3rd).
And also in the 1789 will, there are Gledhill grandsons - these are sons of the late Joseph Gledhill, innholder - so James 1st had a daughter, who married Joseph Gledhill (not found the marriage yet). This could be significant because when I did a soundex search on FreeREG for Gledhills, I came up with Gladwell - and there are Gladwell/Tiffin marriages in Fingringhoe (yes, we're back there) in the 1800s. Could be significant - could be coincidental. The Gledhills are possibly something to do with the dissenting minister Gledhill in Colchester in the early 1700s.
There is mention in
Colchester People of a memorial inscription in St Giles for "Mary wife of James Mansfield, daughter of Charles Tiffin", who is possibly the one born in LDLH in 1767. Just looking through St Giles burials - 22 Jul 1798 would, I think, be referring to her (the reference in Colchester people says she died 18 Jul 17??, but the age is given as 61 - I think it's our Mary, and I think the age should be 31!!!
But from what I can see in
Colchester People, I think that James Mansfield 1st was the son of another (ANOTHER!) James Mansfield (Erm... James Mansfield zero?). Buried in St Giles in 1780, aged 80, his wife was Mary, also buried in St Giles, in 1785, aged 77.
This is about as much as my brain can take for now... time for lunch!