How do you go about verifying trees people post on any genealogical website or published in pedigrees in books?
Well, I suppose I'd have more faith in a published tree than one on a genealogical website. I have a tree on Ancestry. The sheer amount of rubbish I find on other people's trees - I mean, lineages that took me just two minutes to debunk using popularly available stuff like the censuses, or simply by impossible dates of birth, death, and mothers having children only a year after they have been born themselves, stuff that people obviously threw up there without even looking twice at. Supposing those people go for DNA testing? God knows what kind of lineage they will offer to the tree projects.
That brings me back to my example.
108079 Roche William Roche b1820 and d 1890 Ireland I2b
I see on a quick Ancestry search, there is indeed a William Roche born about 1820 and died in 1890 in Cork. My 3rd great grandfather, also a William Roche (though not my direct paternal line) was born about 1812 and died in 1872 in Dublin.
How do I or my cousin know:
a) Who this William Roche is (it's quite vague, isn't it?),
b) How correct his suggested dates are (are they estimates?),
c) Who was tested who put this William Roche on the tree project, and
d) Whether we are related to him - there is no remote connection to Cork anywhere in my tree so far.
All of this seems so vague, and perhaps I am not understanding it well enough. Or perhaps it is all vague anyway, in which case I would wonder whether to bother testing myself at all.
Any opinions? Does anyone understand all this who can explain it better?