Hi Jen
Sounds like you are ploughing through there!
There are so few Christies aren't there originating from Logie Pert. Just a few questions as a little review:
Have you been able to find a marriage date for James Christie and wife Charlotte? Charlotte is showing with her family in Logie Pert (father William and mother Charlotte Wallace?) for 1841. Marriage therefore between 1841-45?
Am I right in thinking there are no children's OPR births or christenings to be found? Maybe a different religeous denomination at that time?
Trying to summarise in my head what children's names we have so far:
Elizabeth born c. 1845 in Logie Pert. Your gg grandmother. You have all her details. Did she ever use a middle name?
Robina born c. 1847 b. England (likely London from what you have found) - possible middle name of Pearce. You have all her details.
James born c. 1849 in Montrose...gone AWOL since 1861 when he showed living with his mother Charlotte in Montrose.
Charlotte born 1850 in Montrose. We have her in the 1881 census we think, still single, and then as a witness to Jane's wedding in 1884. Possible marriage and deaths for her on SP (as always, it is all about managing those SP units!).
Jane Louise born c. 1854 in Milwaukee, US. We have her marriage now and up to 1901 census. She uses a variety of initials to her name. Jane L(ouise) and then either T/D/N etc as a futher initial.
No children show for Charlotte and husband James post 1855.
Completely off in a different wing...Have you ever considered the possibility that James could be illegitimate...
I saw in earlier searches an Elizabeth Christie, a dress maker b. Logie Pert, old enough to be his mother, in the early censuses. Not at all sure that William C and Ann Paxton necessarily connect so far.
Monica