Dear Sid: Thank you for your prompt reply I'm delighted to find potential connections to my pre-North America family!
Although I'm sure we are connected somehow, I fear that I may not be the connection you are looking for. I am definitely NOT related to your 1874 James Creighton.
Elspeth Crichton b. ?Alyth, Perth ca. 1762 d. Nova Scotia 1838
m. Scotland Daniel Graham
HER NEPHEW (Elspeth invited him to come over):
James Crichton I (first to set foot in N. America) b. Forfarshire 1786 d. N.Scotia Feb. 1837 age 51
m. Edinburgh Annie Bell b. Alyth, Perth ca. 1790 d. 1884 NS. 8 sons, 1 dau.
Emigrated 1819 with 2 oldest sons and dau. 6 more sons b. in Nova Scotia
THEIR OLDEST SON:
James Creighton II b. 2 May 1815 Markinch, Fife d. NS 27 Feb. 1898 age 82
m. 1848 Agnes Oliver (Nancy) b. Middle River, NS 27 aug. 1822 d. Gairloch, NS dec, 1901. 5 daus, 3 sons
THEIR 6th CHILD:
James Creighton III b.NS 7 Feb. 1857 d. Eureka, Utah 13 Nov. 1931 [in later life he shaved 4yrs off his age and it consistently appears as 1861]
m. Bannock Cty, Idaho 1 Nov. 1890 Margaret Ann Owens b. San Jose, Ca 1871 d. Eureka, Utah 1939. 4 daus, 1 son
THEIR ELDEST CHILD:
Katherine Agnes Creighton b. Hailey, Idaho 1 Aug. 1891 d. Oakland, CA 1966
m. 1926 Eureka, UT John Thomas Jones b. 20 Jan. 1877 d. Bingham Canyon, UT 22 feb. 1928. One dau. (my mother) --> me --> my children
********
Perhaps you know how my many-greats-aunt Elspeth is related to your David and /or to James I (who I think came from a long line of blacksmiths)? My sure and certain knowledge ends with James I and Annie Bell...
Many thanks, Katherine