What a find Rosie
Sounds very promising to me!:
I just saw yr reply as I was abt to post the following; still posting: They have common names…..the fact your girls were born in England would actually set them apart somewhat in the US Census, if they were in the New York area in 1900 and still as FITZPATRICK - but that's only if they told the truth on census (or their employer's did).
There is no way to tell if these two young women on the Cymric are yours.
In fact the passenger manifest from their arrival in New York - going to a sister, last residence Ireland - points to it not being them. If only we could find the 1900 Census for the address' in New York given on that manifest (I believe both address' are in Manhattan - Mary's on the Hudson side, Janey's on the East River side) but I don't know if it is possible?
Though he is recorded as FITZPATRICK in the 1891 & 1901 Census, if the youngest brother Peter in practice, changed to that of his mother's maiden name BLACK , it's entirely possible the girls did something similar once they were old enough to decide and put such a change into practice.
http://www.rootschat.com/forum/index.php?topic=651420.0This topic tells that the sister Margaret married William BRENNAN (BRANNAN on the Index) in Prescot in (June Qtr) 1901 and that she was the lass in the school in Wales in 1891. Margaret was their only sister.
Who were the witness' to her marriage?
Also, the US Census 1900 recorded the Month and Year of a person's birth. As with any Census, this information could be incorrectly recorded - but what was the exact Birth-dates of both Mary Ellen and Jane (and James, since you're also looking for him)?
Cheers
AMBLY