Just adding this link here from RC on a new post for further background www.rootschat.com/forum/index.php?topic=730461.0
Monica
Hello Monica
I live in the Midlands of England and been in touch with Katie's sister over the Atlantic by email, after her sister made an appeal on another Forum, when a request for their father's Scottish Birth Certificate had already come back no trace.
I contacted off board and we have been making slow, but steady progress. They knew their father had emigrated to Canada on the same ship, as Robert Cochran Harvey, a Cinema Manager (Robert Cochrane Harvey on the May 1926 Marriage Certificate) and his wife Margaret Annie Harvey, nee Burke (Margaret Harvey on the ships list).
However, the Outgoing Passenger List had Alexander MacKay travelling with the Harvey's, but this name, was not the name they knew their father by, so the MacKay name was previously overlooked.
After some checks, I came to the conclusion that their father must have changed his name, from another name, after arriving in Canada, his new name being found in Canadian Voters Registers about a decade later. That is when I searched the Passenger Lists and discovered Alexander MacKay on the same contract ticket.
The sisters then got secondary confirmation from a contact in Scotland who knew the Harvey's sons, that their father was known by McKie, previously.
I managed to find the Cinema Manager, Robert Harvey appeared in a number of Scottish Newspapers - three times in 1934; 1935; twice in 1937; 1938; 1943 and 1948 including two photos of him, at Cinemas in Scottish locations and other information, one in 1943 when Harvey failed to black-out the Playhouse Cinema Perth and the 1943 address checked out, with the Perth address that appears on the 1948 Shipping list.
So we began to build up a documented picture, which corroborated with the verbal information the sisters already had recorded.
The sisters are pursuing other enquiries too and assistance has also been given by a very helpful Registrar, I hear.
Kind regards and thank you, Mark