Hi Gadget,
I think we had always presumed the 1841 to be aged 51 to tie in better. Also the notice of his death in the Kelso Chronicle in 1854 ages his as 66, tying back to 1788.
Hi Lesley,
That's very interesting about the servant tax. John went on to become the gardener for a Mr Innes, at Broomlands in Kelso, the agent for the Duke of Roxburghe. He also won numerous prizes and judged in different Horticultural shows. Possibly there is a sibling also called Robert that would fit too. It would make sense that a 'gardening' parent with links to the upper crust of society would of benefited John, in obtaining the job that he did.
Can I ask what the records showing the Robert are called, and if they are publically available at all?