I agree Sophie, that it is frustrating that no additional notes appeared in the baptism record for Pasquale. I would not be at all surprised if the two Pasquales do turn out to be one and the same. We just need to find something which might support this.
Incidentally, I have found another newspaper article which may be in reference to him. In the Shields Daily News dated Wednesday 9 May 1894, a 'Pasquiline Batista' (sic) was named in an article after being charged with brawling. He was fined 2s 6d. Brawling seems to have been quite common in North Shields at that time. I have found that some of my own ancestors were also brawlers, women as well as men. So glad we are living in much more civilised times now.
I recall now that battista related on another thread that Elizabeth's Step-Father was called Simmons. So she must have decided to use his name as her maiden name at Pasquale's baptism.
https://www.rootschat.com/forum/index.php?topic=794071.9Also, I was wondering if you have ever seen this article. I am guessing the person written about may be your ancestor?
Shields Daily Gazette - Wednesday, 9th April 1884:
'THE NEWCASTLE AUTHORITIES AND SUNDAY TRADING. - Before the Newcastle magistrates yesterday, Vincent Battista, an Italian, appeared in answer to a summons charging him with selling ice cream on the Quayside, on Sunday, the 30th of March.- The Mayor explained that it was the wish of the Bench that persons who sold refreshments ought not to be prosecuted. It did seem hard that persons who sold refreshments on Sundays were prosecuted, while certain trades and the licensed victuallers were allowed to ply their vocations. - Supt. Beattie said they had received instructions from the Watch Committee to prosecute in such cases. The defendant was fined 1d, without costs.'
What an understanding Mayor.