Just trying to get my head round all this
1841 census, Sauchintree, Aberdour
James Robb, 55, born Aberdeenshire
Mary Stuart, 55, Aberdeenshire
1851 census: Backhill of Killyquharn, Aberdour
James Robb, 68, born Keith
Mary Robb, wife, 66, born New Deer
1861 census: South Killy Wharn, Aberdour
James Robb, widower, 78, born Keith
Lydia Birnie, servant, 72, born New Deer
So he was born 1782/1783. There is a gap in the recorded children of George Rob and Janet Ogilvie between 1777 and 1792.
1841 Census: Bluebog, Rathen
John Robb, 66, Aberdeenshire
Jean Robb, 60, Aberdeenshire
1841 census: Village of New Aberdour
Elizabeth Robb, 40
James Robb, 5
Mary Robb, 2
1851 Census: Bluebog, Rathen
George Robb, 40, born Aberdour
Elisabeth Robb, wife, 50, born Aberdour
Alexander Robb, 21, born Aberdour
George Robb, 18, born Aberdour
Mary Robb, 11, born Aberdour
William Robb, 8, born Aberdour
Margaret Campbel, 70, born Aberdour
1861 census: Bluebog, Rathen
George Robb, 50; Elizabeth, 60; Alexander, 31; William, 18; Margaret Campbell, 82, all born Aberdour
1871 Census: Bluebog, Rathen
George Robb, 60; Elisabeth, 70; William, 27; Ann, granddaughter, 11; first three born Aberdour, Ann born Rathen
George died in 1883, and death cert says that his wife was Elizabeth Campbell and parents William Robb and Janet Ogilvie. William could be an error for George.
So what connection is there, if any between John and Jean Robb who were in Bluebog in 1841, and George Robb who was there from 1851 onwards? Are John and Jean the John R and Jean Reid who had two sons John in Rathen in 1814 and 1817? Their banns were called in both Rathen and Lonmay in 1813. John, incidentally, is far too old to be the son of George R and Janet Ogilvie, who was baptised in 1792.
What connection, if any, is there between Elizabeth Campbell or Robb and Margaret Campbell?