Hi Geoff,
He seems to be consistent with having arrived on the Gazelle in 1845.
NSW Gaol Description - 1852 - Stuart McDonald - per Gazelle 1845, on arrival = free, on entering gaol = free, native of Inverness, Protestant, labourer, admitted 3 Jul 1852 from Bathurst. Trial - 3 years hard labour in roads or public works of colony, Quarter Sessions - Jul 15 - Discharged to Sydney Gaol 24 Jul - Offence - horse stealing.
Darlinghurst Description Book - 1852 - Stuart McDonald, age 23, arrived 1845 on Gazelle, 5'7", stout, fresh complexion, brown hair, blue eyes, warts on thumbs, native of Inverness, a tailor.
Darlinghurst Gaol Entrance Book - Stewart McDonald, per Gazelle in 1845, condition on & entering gaol = bond, from Inverness, protestant, a tailor, admitted 4 Aug 1854 from Principal Supt. Convts Office, Purpose = For Cockatoo Island, Disposed of = forwarded 5 Aug 1854
NSW Convicts Records - Stewart McDonald, per Gazelle, 1845. Quarter Sessions Bathurst
15 Jul 1852, sentenced 3 years roads for horse stealing, came free, History:
2 Aug 1852 - Received from Darlinghurst Gaol
31 Aug 1852 - Ordered to Division A Class 3
22 Nov 1854 - Discharged to T. of Leave Scone
5 Aug 1854 - Received from Darlinghurst Gaol - Ticket of Leave cancelled per warrant p.S.C of 4 Aug 1854.
13 Oct 1854 - To serve a probation of 12 months from 4 April 1853. Let. P.S.C. No. 521/95 of date.
5 Feb 1855 - Discharged to Ticket of Leave. Moreton
NSW Police Gazettes - 8 Apr 1854 - District of Scone.
Escaping from custody of the police, Stewart McDonald, a ticket of leave holder for the Scone District, confined in the lock up there under a charge of dray robbery, escaped from custody of the Watch house Keeper, Constable James Evans, on the 4th instance. Description - Stewart McDonald, per ship Gazelle, age 25, trade tailor, height 5' 6 1/2 ", complexion ruddy and a little freckled, hair dark, eyes blueish, remarks - chest prominent, dark mole on left jaw, burnt scar inside right wrist. Constable Evans offers 5 pounds for his apprehension.
Jo