Had a look on https://www.scotlandspeople.gov.uk/ for Josiah John Cato born in Girvan, the only one I could see was born in 1875:Josiah John Cato born 26th December 1875 Parents:Jessie Ensor Cato, gentleman and Jeannie Goudie?. Married 19th July 1867, Otago, New Zealand.There is a marriage for this Josiah John Cato 8/6/1911 Essex Ontario Canada same parents as above but mothers name is Margaret Goudie Can see him in USA as posted ..If raa has a copy of the marriage 1899 to Ellen Burch can maybe compare signatures to rule this chap out Rosie
