Duggan (maybe born 1852) ??? badly in need of a clean up and estimate of date

[Gadget]

720 is the max width before you have to use the slider 

[Aussielass]

Thanks again to everyone for the advice and great restorations.

I have one more favour to ask about another "unknown Duggan".  Do you think this photo is the same person as the c1870's photo that was originally posted.  If it's not o.k. to ask on this post, I will start another one.  Unfortunately the facial features on the first photo are not clearly defined, except for his "injured hand" which is distinctive.  Perhaps if we removed the beard on this new photo he might look the same as the injured hand "Duggan?"

Any advice or opinions would be appreciated.

[Gadget]

Yes 

(but fingers are straight on his left hand! )

Sorry I've posted twice on wrong thread - will remove and put them on Wiggy's!

[chlo]

[chlo]

Do you think this photo is the same person as the c1870's photo that was originally posted.

100%.

[Aussielass]

Thank you Chloe,

Very nice clean up of Thomas Duggan (born 1852), your close up has really defined his features. 

It's now much easier to compare to the later photo I posted with the beard, well done.

Kind Regards,  Aussielass

[Treetotal]

Hi AL...A clean from me of your second image.
Carol

[Aussielass]

Hi Carol,

How are you, hope all is well in your part of the world.  Thanks for the clean up of the 2nd unknown Duggan, he looks great.  I'm still not 100% sure if he is the same person as the 1st "unknown Duggan" that I posted, facial features appear to be the same, but the beard makes him look different.
Kind Regards, Aussielass

[Treetotal]

Fine thank you, hope all is well with you too. You are welcome  I do believe that they could the same person or related.
Take Care.
Carol