Death of Eliza Martha Watterson, nee Martin, 1902, Irwin, Bonneville Co., Idaho

[Peggy13]

I am now looking at a couple William Quigley and Peggy aka Margaret Boothe who had a son Benjamin in 1847. Looking for the other siblings of Benjamin's to verify if this is this family. Margaret Quigley nee Boothe had parents Benjamin Boothe and Mary Ellison. On my tree, I have a James Watterson married to Matilda Boothe, who had father Benjamin, wondering if she is a sister to Margaret Boothe and wondering if they had a daughter Mary Jane  in 1854 who might be 21 yr. old Mary Jane Watterson on the 1875 Geneva census with the Quigley family. If you recall James and Matilda had a daughter Isabelle Dotson who died in Los Angeles in 1948.
All of this bears further research.
Peggy

[*Sandra*]

Sorry got held up on the phone. 

FIND A GRAVE

Margaret Quigley - 1812 - 9 December 1906  (with obituary)

Glenwood Cemetery Geneva, Ontario County, New York.

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/116964028/margaret-quigley

https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:QVG6-XML1

Sandra

We know that the other son was Thomas born 1850 - lived 10 Grant Avenue. Spouse Elizabeth

https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:MSLM-6F8

This might be worth investigating - ancestry tree says the parents of Thomas were :- John Quigley 1820 Londonderry - 1881 and Eliza Boothe 1830 - 21 November 1909 Sligo Ireland ??

Sandra

[*Sandra*]

If this marriage is correct then Thomas born 1850 is listed as the first born. No Benjamin or William ?
This marriage doesn't fit with the birth of William or Benjamin.

Eliza Boothe - Age 22 - Birth Date 1830 - Marriage Date 9 Jan 1852 Magherafelt, Derry, Ireland - Father Benjamin Boothe - Spouse John Quigley.

Sandra

[*Sandra*]

1875 census Geneva, Ontario, New York.  (listed same page - below Benjamin Quigley)

Thomas Quigley Age 26
Elizabeth Quigley Age 24
James Quigley Age 23 Brother
Ester Quigley Age 22 Wife
John Quigley Age 1 Son

https://www.familysearch.org/search/ark:/61903/1:1:VTDD-47W

1900 census Grant Avenue Geneva

Thomas Quigley   50   Head. Teamster.
Elisabeth Quigley 48   Wife
Benjamin Quigley 24   Son
Mary M Quigley 19   Daughter
William Quigley 16   Son
Annie E Quigley 7   Daughter
Margaret R Quigley 6   Daughter

Sandra

[Peggy13]

It would be the Thomas age 26 in 1875 that would be a brother to Benjamin who had his mother Margaret age 55 living with him. Also living with Benjamin is a brother William. All of that bears out with Margaret's obit in 1906. Also a daughter Sarah born Mar 1863 (some records say 1865 but if 1865, Sarah's birth should be on irishgenealogy)married to Charles Coddington and a daughter Mary Jane married to Robert Weir in 1882.
I have been told that Margaret Quigley nee Boothe and Matilda Watterson nee Boothe are not sisters but I still think we are looking at the family of William Quigley and Peggy Boothe in Geneva, New York. William must have died in Ireland.

[*Sandra*]

William Quigley (under Anigkey) is living with Sarah Coddington in 1910 Geneva Ward 5, Ontario, New York,


Sarah Codington 46   Head
William Anigley   65   Brother. Imm 1875. Single. NA. Contractor.
Minnie Codington22   Daughter
Carrie Codington 19   Daughter

and 1900Burrall Avenue Geneva Ward 5, Ontario, New York.

Charles Coddington 40   Head
Sarah Coddington 37   Wife
Meinnia D Coddington 12   Daughter
Carrie Coddington 9   Daughter
William Quigley   55   Brother in Law (Brother-in-law) Imm 1872. Day Labourer. Single.

Sandra

[*Sandra*]

Death of William Quigley - 1 March 1921

FIND A GRAVE

Glenwood Cemetery Geneva, Ontario County, New York.

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/142188458/william-quigley

Sandra

[Peggy13]

So far, the only verified baptism I have is a Benjamin Quigley bapt Oct 3, 1847 at Magherafelt Presbyterian to William Quigley and Peggy Boothe. That fits perfectly with Benjamin age 28 in 1875 in Geneva. Looking for the baptisms of his siblings William age 30 (he must be firstborn son) and Thomas age 26 on this census, also Sarah born 1863 and Mary Jane. Seems like correct family to me but not confirmed as yet.
I just noticed a brother James age 23 living with Thomas Quigley in 1875. If Margaret's obit is correct, and Thomas age 26 is one of Margaret's sons, James must have died before 1906.
James Watterson and Matilda Boothe had a daughter Eliza Jane Oct 15, 1858 who may be the one who married Samuel  Quigley in 1883. Beginning to wonder if Matilda and Margaret could be half-siblings but don't know as yet.

[*Sandra*]

This was the one I was working on 1900 census - Allis Street    Prattsburgh, Steuben, New York.

James Quigley   48   Head.
Esther Quigley 46   Wife. Married 1874.
S James Quigley 22   Son
John C Quigley 20   Son
Thomas L Quigley 17   Son
Anna Quigley 14   Daughter
Benjiman Quigley 12   Son
Florence Quigley 5   Daughter
Charles H Smith 48   Boarder

https://www.familysearch.org/search/ark:/61903/1:1:MSGX-Q6L

1910 Water Street Prattsburg, Steuben, New York.

James Quigley Sr.   57   Head
Esther Quigley 56   Wife
John C Quigley 30   Son
Thomas L Quigley 24   Son
Annie L Quigley 24   Daughter
Benjamin Quigley 21   Son
Florence Quigley 15   Daughter
Mary Henderson 15   Ward
A John Legett 66   Boarder

https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:M54Q-RC8

1915 census - https://www.familysearch.org/search/ark:/61903/1:1:K9PJ-8L

Sandra

1880 census - https://www.familysearch.org/search/ark:/61903/1:1:MSGX-Q6L