Hello Matt,
I’ve just spotted this topic [note to self – always check look-up board as well as the main Berks one!]]
Phoebe Poor and Joseph Head were my 4xgreat grandparents. And he was, indeed, much older than her when they married in 1792 – in fact, about twice her age.
The Phoebe Head that jonw65 identified in Reading in 1841 census is indeed the correct one. The Elizabeth Head with her is probably her granddaughter (parents Joseph Head & Jane Virtue). They are living with Edward and Harriett Emans (transcribed by Ancestry as Emansa) on the previous census page. I think “Harriett” is an error and should be Kezia (as she is in 1851). Edward Emmans and Kesiah Head married at Thatcham on 26 Dec 1825. Edward was landlord of The Little Crown, Horn Street.
I have Phoebe’s death certificate for 7 Dec 1845 at Horn Street. She is shown as the widow of Joseph Head, labourer; and the informant was Edward Emans present at the death.
As with the burial record, her age was given as 72, so a birth around 1773.
In Toomer’s 1815 census of Newbury Phoebe is at Morris’s Yard, west side of Market Place, and shown as a widow with five children. She is aged 43, so a birth around 1772. Also in the same Yard three doors along is John (aged 44) and Susanna Poor, plus children Ann and Sarah. Was he Phoebe’s brother?
Looking for a Newbury baptism around 1772/3 the following appears:
18 Apr 1774 Pheeby, daughter of Sarah Poor, widow
The father’s burial is:
2 March 1774 Thomas Poor
I agree with what you say about Thomas Poor and Christian Lawrence. Although the banns and marriage register show them both of Newbury, the latter notes he is a sojourner. I’ve not got further back than this.
There are two possibilities for Phoebe’s mother Sarah Nalder – which is where I stick.
1 Apr 1748 d/o Robert Nalder & Mary, or
23 May 1753 aged 4 d/o Charles Nalder & Mary (with Elizabeth baptised on the same day)
The Newbury register entries are from Berks FHS transcription for St Nicolas – an essential purchase for folk with deep Newbury connections.
I hope this helps – it’s always useful to have different people come to the same conclusion independently.