Pronunciation help: Croftindaker

[Forfarian]

I've found Croftindacker on a map surveyed in 1870.

However the same spot is clearly marked on a map surveyed in 1926-1927 and on later maps as Croftintaggart.

See attachment and https://www.geograph.org.uk/gridref/NJ1537, which shows where the ruins are and even has a photograph.

I would put the stress on the first a, making it Croft-n-TAG-rt, but am willing to be corrected. It would sound very odd if any other syllable were to be stressed.

The practical difficulty is that since that second map was surveyed in 1926-1927 the croft, whatever its name, has been swallowed up in a forest plantation. So it may not be easy to find someone who remembers hearing it spoken of.

[kathyc]

I've found Croftindacker on a map surveyed in 1870.

However the same spot is clearly marked on a map surveyed in 1926-1927 and on later maps as Croftintaggart.

See attachment and https://www.geograph.org.uk/gridref/NJ1537, which shows where the ruins are and even has a photograph.

I would put the stress on the first a, making it Croft-n-TAG-rt, but am willing to be corrected. It would sound very odd if any other syllable were to be stressed.

The practical difficulty is that since that second map was surveyed in 1926-1927 the croft, whatever its name, has been swallowed up in a forest plantation. So it may not be easy to find someone who remembers hearing it spoken of.

Thanks very much for this. I so appreciate the links and time you've put into helping me. Your pronunciation suggestion makes sense to me, especially given the most common ways the name is represented on census records where it would have been written down presumably as the enumerator heard it, which is Croftindaker or Croftindacker in every census from 1861. Whether it was a D or a T would be very difficult to tell in that sequence of letters.

Thanks again for your help.

Kathy

[Calleva]

I’ve also been puzzling over the evidence with Croftintaggart shown on maps yet ‘Croftindaker’ on the 1861 Census, extract attached, and presumably other sources.

I was having similar thoughts to Forfarian on whether Croftindaker could be derived from Croftintaggart  or vice versa.

Wondering if a Gaelic speaker could comment on whether it is feasible both names written in English could be from the same Gaelic root?

Agree with Forfarian that it may be extremely difficult to find someone locally who remembers hearing the name as the Croft is now ruinous, and in woodland but will still run it past my son.

[kathyc]

I’ve also been puzzling over the evidence with Croftintaggart shown on maps yet ‘Croftindaker’ on the 1861 Census, extract attached, and presumably other sources.

Yes, the statutory records I have for people who lived at that croft also typically say Croftindacker or Croftindaker.

I think the Croftintaggart/daker difference is simply one of lack of spelling consistency. To my ear they sound quite similar when said aloud. But like you, I do wonder about the origin of the name.