Please excuse the length of what follows:
I'm looking at my grandmother's family, the Hiltons in Lancashire. Many years ago my aunt did a lot of research. Unfortunately in her later years she seems to have given most of her finished material, long promised to me, to another relative,
- but, moving quickly on.. I'm picking through all her rough notes. Also she would have liked to find aristocratic, or at least gentrified, connections, so some of her work is rather speculative..
Anyway, my great great grandfather was James Hilton, b 1844. His mother was Mary Hilton. James had a brother, Thomas Worthington Hilton, born 1838. It took me a while to realise that Hilton was Mary's maiden name. There were a couple of vague notes in my aunt's papers to the effect that she was "Mrs Cliff". After several false starts with my searches the penny finally dropped - this very upright, high-Anglican family had an illegitimacy lurking...
I've just obtained James's birth certificate and have discovered that his father is recorded - James Cliff. Mary registered the birth (September 1844).
Several curiosities here:
James Cliff's occupation is turnkey at the New Bailey Prison, Salford. This fits, as my aunt's notes say that Mary's mother, Sarah, was matron there for many years.
James Hilton's marriage certificate in 1880, on his marriage to Elizabeth Gerrard, shows his father as being William Cliffe Hilton, gentleman.
I'm 99% certain that Mary never married. She's shown as unmarried on every census but one, the final one she appears on, that has widow. She's head of household on each census, living with her sons until near the end of her life, when she was with her sister's family. I can find no marriage to James/William Cliff(e) or anyone else.
So what was going on?!
Was James's father William or James, Cliff or Cliffe? (Would the parish records of James's marraige give groom's father's name? If so, I must check those to see what they say).
How did a turnkey end up as a gentleman?
How did he get away with claiming to be called Hilton on the marriage certificate? (Maybe identity checks weren't very stringent in those days).
James married into an extremely respectable family, the Gerrards of Ince Hall, Lancashire. Did the Gerrards know that they were allowing their daughter to marry a bastard - would they have been at all likely to countenance that in 1880? (I don't think the marriage was for an obvious reason - the first child was born 10 months later), or could they have been deceived by the Hiltons?
It's not entirely clear from my aunt's notes whether she realised that James was illegitimate, but I think she must have known or at least had strong suspicions that she left uninvestigated..
I might get Thomas Worthington Hilton's birth certificate to see whether his father is on there (I'm guessing it might be a Mr Worthington). The notes say that Thomas was sent to a posh school in the south of England, while James was educated locally, so maybe Thomas's father paid for his education.
I need to look more closely for William/James Cliff(e), but it's not an uncommon name in the area, and a first glance suggested that there might be several candidates. And which is likely to be correct anyway?
I'd be very interested to hear people's comments and suggestions!