None of them sound familiar to me. This is the area covered by the Caistor Reg Dist ... perhaps you can spot some possible names in the list.
Caistor
Created 1st July 1837.
Sub-districts : Caistor; Great Grimsby; Market Rasen
GRO volumes : XIV (1837-51); 7a (1852-1930).
Ashby cum Fenby (1837-96), Atterby, Aylesby (1837-96), Barnoldby-le-Beck (1837-96), Beelsby (1837-96), Bigby, Bishop Norton, Bradley (1837-96), Brigsley (1837-96), Brocklesby, Buslingthorpe, Cabourne, Caistor, Claxby, Clee (1837-96), Cleethorpes (1837-96), Clixby, Croxby, Cuxwold, East Ravendale (1837-96), East Torrington, Glentham, Grasby, Great Coates (1837-96), Great Grimsby (1837-96), Great Limber, Habrough (1837-96), Hatcliffe (1837-96), Hawerby cum Beesby (1837-96), Healing (1837-96), Holton-le-Moor, Humberston (1837-96), Immingham (1837-96), Irby (1837-96), Keelby, Kingerby, Kirkby cum Osgodby, Kirmond le Mire, Laceby (1837-96), Legsby, Linwood, Lissington, Little Coates (1837-96), Market Rasen, Middle Rasen, Nettleton, Newton by Toft, Normanby le Wold, North Coates, North Kelsey, North Owersby, North Willingham, Riby, Rothwell, Scartho (1837-96), Searby cum Ownby, Sixhills, Snitterby, Somerby, South Kelsey, South Owersby, Stainton le Vale, Stallingborough (1837-96), Swallow, Swinhope, Tealby, Thoresway, Thorganby, Thornton le Moor, Toft next Newton, Usselby, Waddingham, Walesby, Waltham (1837-96), Weelsby, West Rasen, West Ravendale (1837-96), Wold Newton.