Thanks so much ladies
I just typed a response and got timed out and lost it. I was saying that that is indeed the information about Charles Gideon and his sons. He also had a younger son again, John, who fought in the same battalion as he. I assume he would've had to write a letter for him too, being under age. I did find them on the nominal roll for the war, but didn't look much further, as I wasn't sure these were part of my Winters.
Thanks Jenn for confirming that Charles' father was John, as I suspected, he being the only of William and Sarah's sons not mentioned (besides William, the one I think might be mine, ironically enough), and saying there was always a John in the family. So John married a Francis.. hmm I'd guess her surname was Morris...
I wonder when they came out then, as in Charles' correspondance, he states they sailed out in 1879, but says he was 2 at the time... so perhaps he wrote 12 and someone's made a typo... hmm... school in Vic, lived in Tas and Perth... if you do find any information on the whereabouts of John's death or anything, I'd be most interested.
Is it too much of a conclusion to jump to, saying that William and Sarah's son William, b. 1840 in Tenby is the same as my William? Could there have been 2 Williams born that year, whos fathers were named William and were poulterers?? (Actually I think my William was born in late 1839...)
Another 'coincidence' is the property at Narberth is named Redstone... and my GGrandfather came to Aust. and built a home in the 1930s, and it was named Redstone. I'm told it was named after the home they'd moved from, but I wonder if THAT home had been named after the original one back in Wales... AND there's a John in that family as well! lol
Thanks again for the information, I will keep looking for links! I wonder if I can find any descendants of Charles Gideons children...
Leigh