My husband's greatgrandfather was Alfred Butters, and from talking to my aunt in law, I know he came from Norfolk, was married twice, the second marriage being to Rose Ann Lince in Knaresborough in 1913, the first is either Emily Hardisty or Mary Jane Winter at Knaresborough December 1892 and he died in the Harrogate bombings during 1940, but that's all I can find about him, there appear to be a few Alfred Butters living in Norfolk in the 1881 census, but he doesn't seem to appear living in Yorkshire or Norfolk on the 1891 census with a wife Mary Jane or Emily and he isn't on the 1901 census for Yorkshire either although he must have been in Yorkshire by 1892 for his marriage.