Hi Steve
Finally some progress. Where to start! If you have a look on this site, click on the name or unknown next to Primary Maker and you will find Individual ( people ) , Early New Plymouth and surrounding area photographs that may be of interest to you.
http://vernon.npdc.govt.nz/collection/search.do From the Butler Indexes ( by Fred Butler ) These are held in the Library Archives. Fred was an eccentric man who liked to paste clippings and any relevant information in books about Taranaki and New Zealand. There is a story on the Pukeariki Website regarding him and his hobby, but I can't find it.
It doesn't say in the book whether this has been copied from the original document as this piece I have typed below is hand written by Fred Butler. It is dated 7th September 1861.
To his Excellency Colonel James Gore Brown companion of the most honorable order of the Bath?, Governers and Commanders in Chief in and ova Her majesty's Colony of New Zealand and Vice Admiral of the same , etc, etc, etc....
Sir - We, the undersigned, inhabitants of Taranaki, desire apon your Excellency's approaching departure from New Zealand to express our appreciation of your ministration of The Government of this colony and more especially the measures taken by your Excellency in connexion with the Natives of this district, etc, etc, .....
New Plymouth , Taranaki
26 August 1861
signed by the Settlers of New Plymouth/Taranaki ( there are many signatures )
Dalby H A included
I have found him in the Burial Indexes Block B and row 11. There is no inscription in the Inscription Indexes for him.
I have looked on the ships list for Taranaki and so far have only found what you already have. I do need to go back to the library and check a folder for Evacuees to Nelson, June 1860. It wasn't alphabetically listed and I ran out of time. Although I did find a ships list to Nelson for the females evacuating, but it was incomplete.
I couldn't find any information on the Pilchers at all.
This first picture is the Census Returns for Houses at New Plymouth to 31st Dec 1852. In the second section of names he is the 7th person down. Interesting the Census states 2 children under 7 yrs. But it doesn't mention a female adult. Although possibly the wrong box was marked??